Made in USA - Free Shipping $25 and Over

Bay Rum Shaving Soap Refill Puck, 4.0 oz
Bay Rum Shaving Soap Refill Puck, 4.0 oz
Bay Rum Shaving Soap Refill Puck, 4.0 oz
Bay Rum Shaving Soap Refill Puck, 4.0 oz
Bay Rum Shaving Soap Refill Puck, 4.0 oz

Bay Rum Shaving Soap Refill Puck, 4.0 oz

Regular price $ 12.95 Sale

Gives you an extremely close shave. Moisturizes and protects your skin with great thick lather. Leaves your face soft and buttery smooth.

  • 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
  • Vegan & Natural Ingredients
  • Not Tested on Animals
  • Subtle Bay Rum Sent
  • Proudly Made in USA

What you get: 

  1. 4.0 oz Large Shaving Soap Refill Puck
  2. 5 FREE Derby Blades

Key Ingredients: 

  • Glycerin - Creates luxurious lather for skin protection and razor glide
  • Shea butter & Coconut oil - Moisturizes and softens skin
  • Soy - Comforts and condition for softer skin
  • Vitamin E - Heals damaged skin tissue, hydrates, & moisturizes

Natural Vegetable Plant Based Ingredients

All ingredients are from sustainable sources.


Glycerin, Coconut Oil, Sodium Hydroxide (Saponifying Agent), Purified Water (Aqua), Palm Oil (from sustainable sources), Safflower Oil, Sorbitol (Moisturizer), Shea Butter, Soy Milk, Sweet Almond Oil, Titanium Dioxide, Vitamin E, Bay Rum

Ingredients Used in Our Shaving Soap VS. Over-The-Counter Brands


Recommended Reading

Do you hate shaving because your skin feels irritated after every shave?

You see, for many years, we’ve transitioned from using classic wet shaving products to unnatural shaving creams, gels, and soaps, which are full of harsh toxins and chemicals that leave our skin with irritations and razor burns.


We at Men’s Soap Company decided it’s time to help bring back classic shaving by providing exceptional, high-quality shaving products. Let's go back to our grandfather's way of shaving by using straight and double edge safety razors, natural shaving soaps, and a shaving brush.


There are many shaving soaps in the market, but if you want a great premium soap made from high-quality natural ingredients that will leave your skin smooth and moisturized after every shave then you must try our Bay Rum Shaving Soap.


Products we recommend using with our soap: 

  • Quality Synthetic or Horse Hair Shaving Brush
  • Merkur Chrome Long Handled Safety Razor or Merkur Heavy Duty Double Edge Razor 34C
  • Edwin Jagger Porcelain Shaving Soap Bowl

What's the difference between shaving soap vs cream?

Shaving cream can create a quicker thicker lather due to it being foamy, however, shaving soaps add a better layer of protection while shaving. Shaving soap tends to have less fragrance, which is an added benefit if you have sensitive skin.

Which Shaving brush works best?

Shaving brushes can be made from synthetic, horse, boar, or badger hair. To get the best lather and shave that won't be affected by hard water, a synthetic shaving brush is best. You may choose horse hair as an alternative, as cutting a horse mane and tail is part of their regular grooming, which does not harm the horse. We do not recommend boar or badger hair because their hair is harvested by killing.

Customer Reviews

Based on 8 reviews
Almost 5 stars

I wish there was an unscented soap, but the bay rum is the next best because the scent is very light and disappears on my face. The soap lathers quickly and well and doesn’t cause a rash.

Hi Barry, thanks for your feedback. We've been getting more requests for unscented shaving soap recently, which we are definitely considering. We'll let you know when it's released, hopefully in the near future. Thanks, again!
Vegan suds

I have looked for shave soap this good forever. After one week, I am sold!!

Amen to that, Michael. Thank you so much for your feedback and support. We look forward to keeping that positive vibe going as long as you give us the opportunity to do so. Cheers!
Smell lasts

Smell lasts but melts away rather quickly while steeping in hot water. Much faster melt than hymalaya. Cheaper to buy directly from men’s soap than Amazon! Mostly, i like it

Hi, Rich! Thanks for your feedback and support. It's interesting that Bay Rum shaving soap melted faster for you, even though ingredients are the same. As long as you're satisfied is all we care about. Happy shaving!
Best Bay Rum I have used

I have tried several Bay Rum soaps for other places and this is one I I like the clove scent and there is not too much orange or vanilla. To me, this has a great balance of the scent and has that classic feel I envision for a Bay Rum. I was able to get a thick and creamy lather. This makes for a Great Shave!

Dylan, you're right on the money describing the Bay Rum shaving soap scent. Many competitors add different spices to differentiate their brand. Why mess with a classic scent if an't broke? We strive to bring the natural light scent, unlike others that can be too musky for most people. Bay Rum is the house favorite. Glad you agree with us. Thanks for your feedback and support. Happy shaving!
I love this shaving soap

I have now used Men's Soap Co. Bay Rum for 3 weeks, and I say without hesitation that it is great...I love it! I'm 62 years old, so I would guess that I can be considered an "experienced shaver".
A lasting, thick creamy lather whips up easily, and provides a close comfortable shave, leaving my face feeling smooth and hydrated.
This Bay Rum scent is the best of any that I have used. It reminds me of the Bay Rum from years past as I recall it. Prominent but not over powering...just right! After 3 weeks of use I have hardly put a dent in it, so it's going to last a while, making this 4 oz. puck a great value as well. I highly recommend trying this.

They say you can't teach an old dog new tricks. Bill, at 65, we want to bring your wisdom to light. Our goal is to bring back classic shaving as we remembered as a child. Somethings simply cannot be replaced or forgotten, and classic shaving soap scents continue to make strides through generations, as our Bay Rum shaving soap and your feedback is living proof. Thank you sir!